Causal Effects of Modified Treatment Policies under Positivity Violations: A Partial Identification Approach

原文摘要

Modified treatment policies (MTPs) are interventions based on each individual's natural treatment value. We study mean outcomes under MTPs for continuous treatments, including exposure mixtures. Positivity is the standard sufficient condition for identifying these mean outcomes without extrapolation: policy-generated values remain supported given covariates. With multivariate treatments or continuous covariates, treatment--covariate combinations can be sparse or unsupported. Retaining the policy, our partial-identification framework decomposes its mean outcome into a point-identified contribution inside a positivity region and one outside. We bound the latter by imposing Lipschitz continuity on conditional mean potential outcomes rather than a parametric extrapolation model. The restriction compares each outside mean with the mean at an anchor inside the region. Metric projection minimizes width among one-anchor intervals but concentrates anchors on a lower-dimensional boundary, making the endpoints not pathwise differentiable. Our novel interior-displaced projection moves anchors inward, restoring pathwise differentiability. With a known region, we derive influence functions, characterize when they are efficient, and obtain asymptotically normal estimators and confidence intervals. In simulations, our intervals attain at least nominal coverage where those assuming positivity undercover. In a pesticide-mixture application, protective associations suggested by methods assuming positivity are not robust to modest outcome variation beyond the estimated region.

摘要来源：arXiv