每日简报

处理与结果非随机缺失时，工具变量模型的可识别性AI 解读

The instrumental variable model of Imbens and Angrist (1994) and Angrist et al. (1996) identifies the local average treatment effect, also known as the complier average causal effect (CACE). In practice, however, the treatment and outcome are often missing, and when they are missing not at random (MNAR), the CACE is generally not identifiable without further assumptions, because the underlying data distribution itself cannot be recovered. We study when the CACE remains…

宽严度设计：操作指南AI 解读

We develop a step-by-step guide to leniency (a.k.a. judge or examiner instrument) designs, drawing on recent econometric literatures. The unbiased jackknife instrumental variables estimator (UJIVE) is purpose-built for leveraging exogenous leniency variation, avoiding subtle biases even in the presence of many decision-makers or controls. We show how UJIVE can also be used to assess key assumptions underlying leniency designs, including quasi-random assignment and average…

计数反向响应者：实验设计模型提供超越平均效应的证据AI 解读

Using only a binary intervention and outcome and the design of the randomization within an experiment, we construct a design-based likelihood of the joint distribution of potential outcomes in the sample -- the numbers of always takers, compliers, defiers, and never takers. We develop a visualization to show that samples with defiers can sometimes generate the data in more ways than samples without, yielding a higher likelihood. This likelihood can vary within the Frechet…

兼顾未知的证据聚合：学习效应原型与知识边界AI 解读

When evaluating policy interventions, researchers often pursue two related goals: identifying which individuals or contexts benefit most, and determining whether patterns of treatment effect heterogeneity can be used to aggregate evidence across environments. We develop a framework that aggregates treatment effect heterogeneity, defined over individual and environmental characteristics, into interpretable summaries while setting aside contexts in which extrapolation is…

从随机重启中进行推断AI 解读

Random-restart heuristics are widely used in nonconvex optimization and equilibrium computation: practitioners run a local algorithm from many initial conditions and interpret repeated convergence to the same output as evidence that the result is robust, dominant, or even unique. Despite its widespread use, this reasoning is usually informal. We provide a probabilistic framework for interpreting restart evidence. We give broad, easy-to-verify sufficient conditions under…

线性结构方程模型中偏回归系数因果解释的统一图判据AI 解读

This paper provides a graph-based characterization of partial regression coefficients in linear structural equation models. First, we derive a generalized graphical criterion that unifies the d-separation, single-door, and back-door criteria. This criterion provides a generically necessary and sufficient condition under which a partial regression coefficient coincides with a linear causal effect that is not mediated by other explanatory variables. Second, we clarify the…

真实处理不可观测时的因果推断AI 解读

In many causal inference settings, the treatment of interest is not directly observed; instead, one or more error-prone proxy measurements are available, creating a fundamental identification challenge. Building on identification methods for hidden treatments with proxies, we develop a general semiparametric framework for causal effect estimation that accommodates several common estimands. Hidden treatment models differ fundamentally from classical missing-data settings,…

州级政策异质性分析：问题辨析与方法建议AI 解读

State-level policy studies often conduct heterogeneity analyses that quantify how treatment effects vary across state characteristics. These analyses may be used to inform state-specific policy decisions, or to infer how the effect of a policy changes in combination with other state characteristics. However, in state-level settings with varied contexts and policy landscapes, multiple versions of similar policies, and differential policy implementation, the causal quantities…

随机对照试验中 AIPW 估计器 Wald 区间覆盖率的模型无关界AI 解读

Nonparametric estimators, such as the augmented inverse probability weighted (AIPW) estimator, have become increasingly popular in causal inference. Numerous nonparametric estimators have been proposed, but they are all asymptotically normal with the same asymptotic variance under similar conditions, leaving little guidance for practitioners to choose an estimator. In this paper, I focus on another important perspective of their asymptotic behaviors beyond asymptotic…

放宽可迁移性假设的随机试验效应外推：美国选举政治广告案例AI 解读

During the 2020 U.S. presidential election, Aggarwal et al. (2023) conducted a large-scale randomized experiment to evaluate a digital ad campaign against Trump in five battleground states. While the study found no effect on voter turnout, it's unclear whether this null result generalizes to other battleground states, notably Georgia, which played a unique role in the 2020 election and differs from the battleground states. Inspired by the study, we present a transfer…

传统分解与因果分解何时分歧？健康差异研究的实用指南AI 解读

Identifying malleable factors that can reduce social disparities is a central objective among researchers across disciplines. Traditionally, researchers have relied on the difference-in-coefficients and Kitagawa-Oaxaca-Blinder frameworks. More recently, methods grounded in the potential outcomes framework have emerged. While these methods share the same goal of identifying drivers of disparity, they frequently yield divergent results depending on the underlying confounding…

正交化合成控制AI 解读

When conducting inference for the average treatment effect on the treated with a Synthetic Control Estimator, the vector of control weights is a nuisance parameter that is often constrained, high-dimensional, and may be only partially identified even when the average treatment effect on the treated is point-identified. All three of these features of a nuisance parameter can lead to failure of asymptotic normality for the estimate of the parameter of interest when using…

Napkin 因果图下的因果推断AI 解读

Unmeasured confounding can render identification strategies based on adjustment functionals invalid. We study the "Napkin" graph, a causal structure that encapsulates features of M-bias, instrumental variables, and classical back-door and front-door settings, yet identifies the average treatment effect through a nonstandard ratio of two g-formulas. We develop influence-function-based estimators for this functional, including doubly-robust one-step and targeted minimum…

序贯决策中因果效应的置信区间AI 解读

We derive confidence intervals and confidence sequences for causal effects in situations where the back-door criterion is applicable. Our tightest confidence intervals hold in the standard setting where the training data consists of IID observations over a system described by a given causal diagram. When interventions are allowed to depend on the past data, our confidence intervals become wider and involve a term coming from the law of the iterated logarithm, even where the…

最优策略可能不唯一时的半参数离策略价值推断AI 解读

Off-policy evaluation (OPE) constructs confidence intervals for the value of a target policy using data generated under a different behavior policy. Most existing inference methods focus on fixed target policies and may fail when the target policy is estimated as optimal, particularly when the optimal policy is non-unique or nearly deterministic. We study inference for the value of optimal policies in Markov decision processes. In an auxiliary augmented transition-sampling…

利用网络结构的工具变量回归：因果节点发现与估计AI 解读

Estimating causal effects from high-dimensional, structured exposures is a fundamental challenge in modern applications ranging from neuroscience and finance to environmental science. While the literature has addressed high-dimensional instrumental variable (IV) regression, and separately leveraged graph structure in penalized regression, the integration of both, especially for causal support recovery in the presence of latent confounding, remains unexplored. In this work,…

非可分选择模型估计：函数压缩映射方法AI 解读

We propose a novel method for estimating nonseparable selection models. We show that, for a given selection function and under suitable contraction conditions, the potential outcome distributions are nonparametrically identified from the selected outcome distributions and can be recovered using a simple iterative algorithm. This result enables a full-information approach to estimating selection models without imposing parametric or separability assumptions on the outcome…

存在单位间干扰时的低秩协变量平衡估计AI 解读

A key methodological challenge in observational studies with interference between units is twofold: (1) each unit's outcome may depend on many others' treatments, and (2) treatment assignments may exhibit complex dependencies across units. We develop a general statistical framework for constructing robust causal effect estimators to address these challenges. We first show that, without restricting the patterns of interference, the standard inverse probability weighting (IPW)…

连续处理下的多重稳健因果中介分析AI 解读

In many applications, researchers are interested in the direct and indirect causal effects of a treatment or exposure on an outcome of interest. Mediation analysis offers a rigorous framework for identifying and estimating these causal effects. For binary treatments, efficient estimators for the direct and indirect effects are presented by Tchetgen Tchetgen and Shpitser (2012) based on the influence function of the parameter of interest. These estimators possess desirable…

从联合分析数据学习偏好：结构模型与深度学习的混合方法AI 解读

Conjoint experiments randomize multidimensional profiles, yet political science applications typically report only nonparametric averages that do not recover counterfactual choices or individual tradeoffs. We develop a hybrid structural approach for recovering individual preferences from conjoint data. The estimator combines a flexible machine-learning mean preference function, via a deep netural network in our applications, with respondent-level empirical-Bayes updating in…

随机实验中成对数据的因果推断AI 解读

Estimating treatment effects in networked settings is a central challenge in online controlled experiments, particularly on social media platforms. We investigate a scenario where the unit-level outcome of interest comprises a series of dyadic outcomes that record pairwise interactions between units, spanning from point-to-point messaging at the microscale to bilateral trade flows at the macroscale. Because the response is defined at the dyadic level, the treatment assigned…

测地空间中的因果推断AI 解读

Adjusting for confounding and imbalance when establishing statistical relationships is an increasingly important task, and causal inference methods have emerged as the most popular tool to achieve this. Existing methodology has been developed primarily for outcomes that lie in Euclidean spaces. We introduce here a general framework for causal inference when outcomes reside in general geodesic metric spaces, where we draw on a novel geodesic calculus that facilitates scalar…

因果泛函中变量离散化导致的粗化偏差AI 解读

Causal identification functionals often require integration over conditional densities of continuous variables, such as those arising in nonparametric identification theory of total and mediated causal effects in DAGs with hidden variables. Estimating these densities and evaluating the resulting integrals can be statistically and computationally demanding. A common workaround is to discretize the continuous variable and replace integrals with finite sums. Although…

存在个体间干扰时的因果推断敏感性分析框架AI 解读

In many applications of causal inference, the treatment received by one unit may influence the outcome of another, a phenomenon referred to as interference. Although there are several frameworks for conducting causal inference in the presence of interference, practitioners often lack the data necessary to adjust for its effects. In this paper, we propose a weighting-based sensitivity analysis framework that can be used to assess the systematic bias arising from ignoring…